As an Amazon affiliate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. Please read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy.
If you’re trying to decide between a swim spa vs a pool, there are some things you should know.
It may seem like a tough decision at the moment. However, once I break down the major differences between the two, you may have a better idea of which one to get.
There are no hard pros and cons in this blog post. As far as I’m concerned, you’ll get enjoyment from either choice.
There are, of course, important things to consider before you make a big purchase like this.
Ultimately, it boils down to what you can afford, how much space you have, and how often you’ll be able to enjoy your purchase.
Keep reading for a full list of things to consider before choosing between a swim spa vs a pool.
Key Differences Between a Swim Spa vs a Pool
One of the most obvious differences between a swim spa vs a pool is the size. In-ground pools require a larger footprint. They’re ideal for open areas and tend to be the centerpiece of your outdoor space.
Swim spas, on the other hand, are a great choice if you have limited space. They’re also a more portable option, allowing for installation flexibility.
Besides these obvious differences, I’ve included a few things you may not have thought about.
Reality Check: What Do You Envision?
When you close your eyes and imagine your new “toy” in the backyard, are you thinking of awesome water workouts or family fun?
If you’re trying to convince the family that a spa pool will be great for pool parties, you might want to rethink that scenario.
A swim spa is more compact and great for individual exercise, while a pool offers ample space for group activities. If your vision involves hosting large gatherings, a larger pool might be the better option.
How Much Outdoor Space Do You Have?
A swim spa might be a great choice if you have limited space. Although you can buy a small pool, it might not give you what you were hoping for, especially if you have a family.
Swim spas are ideal for smaller areas and can often be installed where in-ground pools would be impractical.
On the other hand, if you have ample space, a pool can become the centerpiece of your backyard, complete with a deck, landscaping, and even a spa pool or in-ground spas for added relaxation.
Can You Manage the Upkeep?
One of the key factors to consider is maintenance.
Traditional pools require regular cleaning, chemical balancing, and more water treatment compared to a swim spa.
Swim spas typically use less water, making them easier and more affordable to maintain.
Additionally, swim spas often come with well-insulated covers, which reduce heat loss and keep maintenance energy costs lower.
For first-time pool owners, the simplicity of a swim spa might be the best option.
Where Do You Live?
Your location plays a significant role in deciding between a swim spa vs a pool.
If you live in a region with colder winters, a swim spa with dual temperature options can be used year-round.
Swim spas often feature built-in jets and adjustable swim jets, making them a great option for both fitness and relaxation, even during the cold months.
A traditional pool, however, might have a shorter swim season unless it’s heated or located indoors. This makes a swim spa the ideal choice for those in cooler climates.
Is the Goal Fitness or Fun?
While both options offer unique benefits, your personal preferences matter. A swim spa is designed for aquatic exercise and comes with features like adjustable swim jets for resistance training.
It’s like having your own piece of exercise equipment in the backyard.
The benefits of a pool, however, include space for recreation, family bonding, and social events.
Pools are a great way to host a pool party or simply relax on a hot summer day.
Energy Consumption of a Swim Spa vs a Pool
Energy efficiency is a major consideration when comparing a swim spa vs a pool. Pools require a lot of energy for filtration, heating, and circulation, especially in-ground pools or weather pools exposed to outdoor elements.
For more information on the energy consumption of pools, read: Monthly Electrical Costs to Run a Swimming Pool: What Should You Expect?
In contrast, swim spas are more energy-efficient due to their smaller size and well-insulated covers, which minimize heat loss.
They’re a better option if you’re concerned about energy consumption and keeping operational costs low.
Other Key Factors to Consider
In addition to the points noted above, there are a few other things to take into consideration.
Pets in the Water
Do you plan to include your pets in the fun? If so, a traditional pool might be more practical. Swim spas are designed for human use, and their water quality may be harder to maintain if pets frequently join you.
Added Costs
Both options come with upfront costs, but there are differences to consider.
A pool often requires excavation, a concrete pad, and significant landscaping.
Swim spas, on the other hand, are a more portable option and typically need only a flat surface and an electrical connection.
Year-Round Use
Swim spas are designed for year-round use, making them an excellent choice for those who want both warm and cold months covered.
Many models include features like higher temperature settings and general relaxation benefits, making them versatile.
Safety
Safety is a critical factor when choosing between a swim spa vs a pool.
Many places have strict regulations about keeping traditional pools fenced in with barriers to prevent accidental access.
According to the International Association of Certified Home Inspectors, pool guidelines recommend that “the top of a pool barrier be at least 48 inches above grade, measured on the side of the barrier which faces away from the swimming pool.”
The U.S. Consumer Product and Safety Commission (CPSC) report that from 2019 to 2021, an average of 358 children fatally drowned in pools or spas. Where the location was known, 81% of fatal child drownings happened in residentail settings.
If the swim spa or pool you’re considering doesn’t come with a safety cover, make sure to include one in your purchase. For added safety, they should be able to securely lock in place when not in use.
Final Decision: Swim Spa vs Pool
Deciding between a swim spa vs a pool ultimately depends on your specific needs and available space.
For fitness enthusiasts or those with limited space, a hydropool swim spa with unique features like dual temperature options might be the perfect swim spa for you.
Whatever you choose, both are a great way to enjoy the outdoors and enhance your lifestyle.
Consider your personal preferences, budget, and the key factors we’ve discussed to make the final decision that’s best for you.