As an Amazon affiliate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. Please read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy.
I’ve heard people say there isn’t much difference between a hot tub vs a pool. I don’t agree at all! In fact, I think the only similarity is that they both contain water.
There are a lot of things to consider before making a major purchase and both hot tubs and pools are considered (in my opinion) a major purchase.
The decision goes well beyond whether you’d rather soak in a hot tub or do laps in a pool. Keep reading for a full list of everything to consider before placing an order.
Swimming Pools are for Extroverts Who Love Social Gatherings
When I think about traditional swimming pools, my mind goes straight to “pool parties”. I think of busy, noisy, family fun during the hot summer months.
Now, I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with that.
People buy swimming pools for a variety of reasons. For example, a pool is a great choice for water aerobics.
For some people, especially those over 50, a traditional swimming pool offers great health benefits. Pools are perfect for low-impact exercise and are easy on the joints.
They’re also the perfect congregating spot for family gatherings.
People with pools have big backyards or at least enough space to accommodate this kind of water feature on the property.
They enjoy spending time outside with family and friends. They enjoy meeting the neighbors and their children.
In fact, pool people thoroughly enjoy being the hang-out spot on a hot summer day.
Are YOU a pool person?
Hot Tubs are for Introverts
Hot tubs, at least to me, represent a quieter life style. Hot tubs are great for muscle relaxation after a workout. I especially love a hot tub on a cool winter night.
The few steps from the house to the hot tub are freezing, but the rush you feel when that that hot water settles around your collarbone is worth it.
Hot tubs make for a relaxing evening soak, even during the coldest months of winter. On really cold nights, I wear a tightly knitted winter cap to stop my hair from freezing.
Hot tubs are perfect for quiet conversations with family or friends.
There’s nothing quite like leaning your head back and gazing across the night sky, unwinding after a long day.
Hot Tub vs Pool: 11 Things Worth Considering
I’ve given you a few examples of the differences between hot tubs vs pools above.
They’re both great options, but if you can only afford (or only want) one or the other, there are some things to think about first. Obviously, your personal preferences will play a role in what you choose.
That said, there could be some practical matters that may change your purchasing decision.
1. Water Safety: Hot Tub vs Pool
When swim season rolls around, it’s a great idea to consider whether a hot tub or a pool is the better fit for your home.
The most important thing to consider before a making a purchase is water safety, especially if you have small children (or nosy neighbors).
In the U.S., homeowners can be held liable if someone gets hurt or drowns in their pool, even if they had permission to use it.
This is known as premises liability.
To minimize risk, it’s essential to have proper safety measures in place, such as fences, locked gates, and warning signs.
Many homeowners also carry liability insurance to protect themselves in case of an accident.
Pool & Hot Tub Safety Statistics
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), drowning is the leading cause of death for children ages 1 to 4.
Each year, an estimated 4,000 fatal unintentional drownings occur in the U.S., averaging 11 deaths per day.
There are approximately 8,000 nonfatal drownings annually, averaging 22 incidents per day.
2. What are your local regulations concerning a hot tub vs pool?
Before you decide between a hot tub vs a pool, it’s crucial to check your local regulations.
Many areas have specific safety regulations regarding both options. For example, hot tubs require safety covers to prevent accidents, while pools might need fencing or other barriers to ensure safety.
Pools typically require ample space, whereas hot tubs can fit into smaller areas more easily.
Make sure to review zoning laws and permit requirements in your area.
3. How much energy consumption does each use?
Pools, especially larger ones, can have high energy costs due to heating, filtration, and maintenance.
On the other hand, portable hot tubs are generally more energy-efficient and cost less to operate.
While both options will add to your energy bill, a hot tub’s smaller size means lower overall costs compared to a full-sized pool.
4. How much ongoing maintenance is there in a hot tub vs pool?
Both pools and hot tubs require regular maintenance to keep the water clean and safe.
You’ll need to manage sanitizer levels, remove organic material, and maintain proper filtration systems.
Large pools require more frequent upkeep compared to hot tubs.
Spa owners typically find that hot tubs are easier to maintain because they hold less water and have different filtration needs.
The following is a breakdown of the daily, weekly, and seasonal maintenace required for a pool:
Daily Pool Maintenance Tasks
Daily maintenance involves skimming the surface regularly. That helps remove leaves and other organic matter (insects, debris).
You’ll need to check the water level to make sure the pump can work effectively as well.
Testing water chemistry periodically helps maintain the right balance of pH, chlorine, and alkalinity to avoid bacteria growth and keep the water clear.
Weekly Pool Maintenance Tasks
Test the water every week.
Check the pH, chlorine, and alkalinity levels. Adjust the chemicals to keep the water safe. Shock the pool to kill bacteria and algae. Clean the pool filter to remove dirt. Vacuum the pool to get rid of debris.
Look for cracks or damage around the pool. Add algaecide to prevent algae growth. Make sure the pool jets are working correctly. Clean the pool cover to remove dirt and leaves.
Monthly or Seasonal Pool Maintenance
Deep clean the pool tiles and walls.
Check for cracks or leaks in the pool. Service the pool heater and other equipment. Replace or clean old filters if needed. Test the water condition and replace some water if necessary.
Make sure all safety features, like ladders and covers, are in good shape.
The following is a breakdown of the daily, weekly, and seasonal maintenace required for a hot tub:
Daily Hot Tub Maintenance
The daily maintenance requirements of a hot tub are similar to those of a pool, it just doesn’t take as long.
First, you’ll need to check the water level to make sure it’s not too low.
Remove leaves, bugs, and debris with a skimmer. Test the water for pH and sanitizer levels. Adjust the chemicals if needed. Run the jets to keep the water moving.
Keep the cover on when not in use to trap heat and keep dirt out.
Weekly Hot Tub Maintenance
You’ll want to check the pH level of the water every week. Test the water for pH, alkalinity, and sanitizer. Adjust the chemicals to keep the water safe. Rinse the filter to remove dirt and debris.
Wipe down the hot tub shell to prevent buildup. Check for any signs of leaks or damage.
Monthly Hot Tub Maintenance
It’s important to deep clean the hot tub filter on a monthly basis instead of just rinsing it. You soak the filter in a specialized cleaner to remove oils and debris.
Check hoses, jets, and fittings to ensure there are no loose or leaking parts.
Other maintenance requirements that should be completed monthly include:
- Use a stronger shock treatment to break down oils, lotions, and buildup
- Test for calcium harness
- Check for foam buildup
Quarterly Hot Tub Maintenance
Drain and refill the hot tub every 3 to 4 months. Over time, chemicals and debris build up, making it important to completely change the water.
In addition, you should also:
- Clean and condition the shel using a non-abrasive cleaner
- Inspect the heating elements for scale buildup and clean if necessary
- Lubricate moving parts like cover lifters or jet valves
- Inspect electrical components to make sure they are in good condition
- Clean the hot tub cover with a UV protectant to prevent cracking
5. What are the installation requirements of both?
Installation of an Inground Pool
Before beginning the installation process, you’ll need to get the necessary permits. You’ll also need to consult with a local zoning office early in the planning process.
This will help you avoid big issues down the road.
Once you have the go-ahead, the next steps include:
- Excavation to prepare the ground with a solid foundation
- Plumbing and electrical systems must be installed
- Once the pool shell is placed, additioal work like decking, fencing, and landscaping is usually required.
The entire process can take weeks to months to complete.
Costs
The initial cost of installing an inground pool can range from $35,000 to $100,000 or more.
This does not include the cost of the pool itself. Prices vary from $25,000 to $70,000 or more depending on the pool type, size, shape, and additional features like heating and lighting.
Installation of a Hot Tub
Installing a hot tub also requires planning and meeting local regulations.
Before installation, you may need to obtain permits, but these do not automatically ensure your property meets zoning requirements.
It’s important to check local codes for placement restrictions, such as required distances from property lines, fences, and structures.
A stable, level surface is essential, often requiring a concrete pad, pavers, or reinforced decking to support the weight of the filled tub.
Electrical work is another key consideration, as hot tubs typically require a dedicated circuit and GFCI protection.
Proper drainage and access for maintenance should also be factored in. Consulting local authorities and professionals can help ensure your hot tub is installed safely and legally.
Costs
A hot tub is much more affordable to install, typically ranging from $3000 to $15,000 depending on the model, size, and features.
This does not include the cost of the hot tub itself. Prices vary depending on size and extra features.
6. Do you have a big backyard?
Having a big backyard is important if you want to install a pool.
Pools take up a lot of space and need extra room around them for decks and fences.
You also need space for pool equipment like filters and pumps.
A hot tub, on the other hand, needs much less space. You can place a hot tub on a small patio or even on a deck. That said, you’ll need to check if the structure can support the weight.
Reinforcements may be needed.
Generally speaking, hot tubs fit in smaller areas and are easier to install.
7. How soon do you want to get in the water?
An inground pool is a great way to increase the overall value of your home. Unfortunately, they can come with a high price tag and a lot of maintenance.
Installing an ingrown pool will require excavating, which isn’t a quick job.
After the pool installation you’ll then need to fill the pool with water and ensure the chemicals are balanced. It could be weeks to months before you can cannon ball.
Portable spas, especially plug-and-play models that run on standard 110V outlets, can be set up quickly.
8. What kind of climate do you live in?
Your local climate plays a big role in choosing between a hot tub and a pool.
People in colder climates can enjoy a hot tub year-round, while a traditional pool is usually only usable during warmer months.
If you want to enjoy the water in all seasons, a hot tub is a better option because it provides higher temperatures and better insulation.
9. Have you considered a swim spa to get the best of both worlds?
If you’re torn between a pool vs a hot tub, a swim spa might be the perfect compromise.
Swim spas provide space for exercise while also offering the relaxation of a hot tub.
Many models even come with separate sections for swimming and soaking, making them a great option for the whole family.
10. Are you prepared for the maintenance costs?
Both pools and hot tubs come with maintenance costs, but it’s important to consider energy efficiency and initial investment.
Pools generally have higher ongoing expenses due to water, energy, and cleaning supplies, while hot tubs tend to be more affordable in the long run.
Summary
Choosing between a hot tub and a pool depends on factors like space, budget, maintenance, and how quickly you want to start enjoying the water.
If you have a small yard and want year-round relaxation, a hot tub might be the right fit.
But if you’re looking for a larger space to swim and entertain, a pool could be worth the investment.
Whatever you choose, make sure to prioritize safety and enjoy your time in the water!